Elmo

Claim
marker

156 7th Ave, New York, NY 10011
New York, NY 10011

marker
(212) 337-8000
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Reviews
( 11 )
( 33 )
( 13 )
( 15 )
( 9 )

Best

I love this restaurant. The staff if always friendly, and the food and drinks are alwaysgreat. It's a great place for lunch too, with outside dining. The atmosphere is excellent a...

Worst

All I have to say is that looks can be very decieving!!! The place looked great but it was the worst dining experience that I have ever had. The drinks had NO alcohol, the service...

I've managed to have breakfast, brunch, lunch... 9/24/2007

I've managed to have breakfast, brunch, lunch and dinner here, and I can't say I walked away disappointed... more
Reply | Report abuse |

I've managed to have breakfast, brunch, lunch... 9/24/2007

Raxotoxin Provided by Partner
I've managed to have breakfast, brunch, lunch and dinner here, and I can't say I walked away disappointed by anything but the price. But this is N... more
Reply | Report abuse |

The worst service ever!!!! rude and unattentive!!! 8/27/2007

After wondering around Chelsea for about an hour trying to decide on a place to have lunch we finally settled on Elmo. This place place had the modern yet cozy atmosphere and the food sounded great. We ordered eggs benedict and the blueberry pancakes that were supposed to some with lemon whipped butter which sounded great. When the food came out our waitress didn't come up to us even once to ask how everything was instead I must have called out her like 10 times while she zoomed past us. Finally we asked the bus boy for some butter, his responce was ""what are you talking about?? and made us point it out on the menu that indeed it was supposed to come with it!!"" Then when we were attempting to eat the cold pancakes on which the butter wasn't even melting because they were so cold. the waitress finally came over to ask if things were ok. I told her that we were waiting for the butter for so long hat now our pancakes are frozen she said oh sorry and walked away Pros: Nice decor, pretty good food Cons: Terrible service, rude and unattentive waitress more
Reply | Report abuse |

Poor Food, Worse Service 6/24/2007

I had the cod in a dill sauce with golden beets. The cod was over-cooked, rubbery and the sauce gave no taste of dill. My friend had the lobster roll, and said -- with great disappointment -- that it was lacking in any flavor. The waiter had big arms and manicured eye-brows, and maybe thought this put him above the need to offer table service. He simply wasn't around. Feeling unsatisfied, we splurged on the coconut layer cake. It was dry. The folks sitting next to us were brought someone else's food, and never actually got their own. They were issued an apology from the management, although not in person. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Refreshing Alternative to Cafeteria 6/14/2007

When Cafeteria seems too ""cool"" for me... I like to head over to Elmo's. The service may not be up to par but they are always friendly. Outside seating is also a plus and the decor inside, a bit ecclectic, works for some crazy reason. Frozen margaritas are to DIE for! The mac' and cheese is just as good as Cafeteria's. The salad nicoise is yummy, but slightly overpriced for the amount. But if you go... You MUST get the yellow fin tuna sandwich! YUUUUUUUUUUUUMMM!!! Pros: Menu, Outside seating more
Reply | Report abuse |

tomato soup served with mini grilled cheese? count me in! 1/12/2007

Okay, so it's a bit ridiculous, and a bit too clever/cutesy for its own good, but beneath the facade of cool (and the waaay overpriced house cocktails) is a surprisingly good restaurant. I went with a large group of friends and the wait staff was courteous to a fault (even when all my friends decided to show up late). Everyone enjoyed their meals, but I will say that dessert is passable. Pros: Good food, moderate price, nice service Cons: A bit showy, even more ""scene-y"" more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great First-Date Location! 11/1/2006

I went on a first date here and had a great time. Food was outstanding. (He had tuna, I had salmon). Service was fantastic. Ambiance was wonderful. (We sat outside). We weren't rushed at all, our server was very nice and I think we even drew something at the table without any weird stares..... and, we're still dating. ;) Pros: Amazing Seafood. Nice Servers. Cons: No complaints! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Hot Waiters, Good athmosphere, Good food. 9/27/2006

The place is in a really trendy part of town so you expect to pay more. The drinks are a min. of $10 (my mojito was very good but I don't think it's $10 worth of goodness). Pros: Great food and athmosphere Cons: A bit more expensive but probably average for this part of town. more
Reply | Report abuse |

great food, good service 8/16/2006

My partner and I went there on a Thursday night and had a great time. The music was good and the food was fabulous. My recommendation, if you like spicy, try the Island Tacos. These should be a signature dish if they're not already. The food from beginning to end was great and the service was good but not exceptional. If you want hip and trendy at an affordable price without the attitude, Elmo is the place to go. Pros: atmosphere, great food more
Reply | Report abuse |

AVOID if you like to receive your food, have an attentive waiter and enjoy your meal. AWFUL experience 7/30/2006

I am APPALLED by the service I received at Elmo. We were the only two people sitting out front and the waiter was unable to provide us with attentive service OR our dinner. We both ordered something very simple off the menu & we NEVER received it. After 45 minutes, we asked our waiter where our dinner was... like a child caught with his hand in the cookie jar, he could barely answer the question and stood there stupified. He provided us with a free appetizer and asked us our order again (he forgot to place the order). After another half hour, we called it quits. Again, we NEVER received our dinner. We asked for our check (to pay for our drinks and leave), and received the quickest service all evening. Again, I am appalled by the service at Elmo. I DO NOT RECOMMEND this restaurant. Again, I DO NOT RECOMMEND this restaurant. There are plenty of other restaurants in this city that cater to the guest. Elmo is not one of them. Cons: Wait staff ignores the guests more
Reply | Report abuse |

my new favorite spot 5/5/2006

I was entertaining a few guests this weekend who are used to the trendy places with good food/atmosphere, so i decided on Elmo.. Great idea!! We were all very pleased with the friendly (and i must mention good looking) staff who didnt think they were too fabulous like in some other chelsea spots, the new menu was delicious, and just the overall vibe was fun. My friends were very satisfied especially since there was great music playing and art hanging(they are in the entertainment biz). we will all definately be going back there. Pros: friendly staff, cool atmosphere, food selection Cons: cant smoke "outdoors" more
Reply | Report abuse |

LOVED THIS PLACE 5/2/2006

I have had several great nights at elmo which somehow manages to be super trendy without having the attitude. The food had improved dramatically since it first opened and there a many itmes on the American bistro menu that I actually crave. Sure, it's noisy and the wait for a table can take a while but that's the price you pay in New York for being in the right place. For the price there's no better place for good food and a great scene. Pros: sheer fun, great value, very hip Cons: often long wait more
Reply | Report abuse |

Overstuffed Staff 12/5/2005

A lot of staff walking around, looking around. First, we were seated at a blistering hot table in the back. Then, we were approached by a completely pretentious waiter who cared more about his Chap Stick than his tip. And finally when the food arrived it was wrong, and apparently my fault! Mr. Chap Stick didn't bother to write anything down and when the food came out from the kitchen incorrectly, he had the audacity to tell me that I had ordered what was now in front of me. He never bothered to return after my food came out a second time, nor did he make any apologies for his mistake. He then applied more Chap Stick. Perhaps he was overwhelmed with the 3 tables he had during the lunch rush! Pros: Heat works, Chapped lip aid Cons: Rude, Attitude, Lousy food more
Reply | Report abuse |

Just eye candy 11/23/2005

This place is much like its waiters, just eye candy. We were there for Sunday brunch. Ordered the hot home fries but it was nothing but roasted potatoes. We thought the waiter mixed up the order so we sent the potatoes back, but the waiter came back and said that was the spiciest possible, I had a taste and it was still bland like oatmeal! But as consolation we were offered tabasco sauce to remedy the situation. Also when we asked for water refill no one came, but I guess this is just typical. Bottom line is: come here for the drinks, decor and ambience. I'm sure some people will think this is a hip place. But foodies need to stay away. Pros: Decor, Ambience, Cute Waiters Cons: Food, Service more
Reply | Report abuse |

The Service will keep me away 11/13/2005

My friend and I went for lunch the other day during our lunch hour. The staff there are not attentive at all. In fact, when we asked for help, we were ignored! When our food was delivered (eons later) it was warm. Our waiter never came back to check on us and we had to ask to get our water refilled. We again had to ask for our check (eons later) and had to rush out of there to get back to work. We didn't feel welcome there and won't go back. Cons: The service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Baffling Incompetence Behind the Bar 11/13/2005

Stopped in here for an afterdinner drink with friends the other night. The place is pleasant enough, and the music's solid. But stay away if you're serious about your beer. Ordered a pint of Guinness, and the bloke simply filled up the glass as if it were a Budweiser. I asked for a pint pulled the real way, and he gave me a blank stare. ""Well, most people don't like to wait,"" he shrugged. After a little cajoling, he agreed to pull me another pint--which he again mucked up. Mr. Elmo, if your bar is going to carry Guinness, and charge $7(!) for the pleasure, please teach your bartenders how to pour it, okay? Sheesh. Pros: Music Cons: Bartending more
Reply | Report abuse |

Comfort Food for Good Value in Chelsea 8/15/2005

Elmo looks cool from the outside and the DJ beside the bar is an unexpected treat. Loud, but not obnoxious. Dress is very casual, your tank top and shorts will fit in fine here (my date and I were way overdressed). Menu is American comfort food, they make stuff here that you're too tired or pressed for time to make at home (Fried chicken, meatloaf, etc). And it's quite reasonably priced. Overall, a good place to go with friends but not a date. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Lovely Ourdoor Brunch 6/24/2005

I love elmo for brunch. They have seating outside in the sun where you can just relax and watch the world go by. The ceaser salad is amazing and the scrambled eggs are awesome. Don't forget to order a raspberry lemonade or your brunch will not be complete! Pros: outdoor seating, good prices, cute waiters more
Reply | Report abuse |

Cool place 5/1/2005

My friends and I came here last night, and it was fun. We were seated promptly, but the waiter was a little slow to take our order. The food and drinks were good, and the prices were even better. Come here if you want to see good-looking waitstaff. Of course, looks aren't everything, but it doesn't hurt to have eye candy serving your food. The ambiance was very nice. Overall, a good experience. Pros: price, ambiance more
Reply | Report abuse |

OK 1/7/2005

The food at Elmo was OK. I had a 12 dollar cheeseburger with mediocre fries. It is convinient and did not have a wait, which is why we choose it over other resturants, I feel that I now know why there was no wait. more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next >
Menu for Elmo


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Editorial

  • The Scene
    Oversized rainbow-striped banquettes, mid-century-inspired chairs and bright mosaics do justice to the bubbly, urban take on comfort food served up nightly at Elmo. The bar is...

  • 12/12/2006 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: Monday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM Tuesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM Wednesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM Thursday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM Friday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM Saturday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM Sunday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Payments: Discover, Visa, American Express, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods: Midtown, Chelsea
badge