Living in Manhattan, one would not expect to have to go to Tarrytown for an exceptional meal which does not break the bank. However, I would gladly drive the hour for another dinner we had last Friday night. Every moresel that both my date and I had in this place was delicious. The dining room seats only about 35 guests so expect to make reservations. And keep them! It's more than worth it.
Pros: Amazing food; great service; very pleasant ambiance
Cons: none except it's not in NYC