The Blue Gill Grill sits next to Lake Lansing and offers great drinks in a fun atmosphere (and a funny game in the Men's restroom--seriously, its the urinal olympics). Nonetheless, I found the food to be marginal. The salads are made with iceberg lettuce, and the dinner I ordered was just blah and left much to be desired. However, I did not order their fish specialty, so i cannot speak to that.
Pros: by the lake, good beer, fun atmosphere
Cons: mediocre food