I saw some people on here rated this place a three, while most others rated it a ten. I don't know how those people can rate it a three. Did they do something, (come in drunk, loud and obnoxious) to receive poor attention or service, or to take away from the taste of the food. I have been there several times and take it from a true Italian...Benito II's food is consistently wonderful and tastes like Nonna is back in the kitchen. The service, small/cozy atmosphere, and price, topped by the food make this #1 in NYC!
Pros: Taste, Service/Atmosphere, Price
Cons: Can't think of any..., No parking???