The owner of Atlantis Roofing was really good. He was the guy I talked to first, as a salesman, and he was good. He was the reason I hired them. However, the supervisor doing the construction wasn't the best. He was good enough, but he had 6 workers under him and they weren't consistent. One worker was good, and another wasn't, and then the rest were so-so.
They needed a little bit more team work, and the craftsmanship is just so-so. I got a whole new roof, and 90% of it looks good. The middle of the roof pops out a bit, and since it is a brand new roof I am not too happy about that. However, 90% is okay.
I think mostly it is an internal problem. I would not recommend them unless they change supervisors. I felt that their attention was not on me, and that I was not a priority. Price wise they were very good. The other guys were much more expensive, so that is why I went with Atlantis Roofing.