We discovered All-American Pizza purely by accident. Not be confused with the chains, they use real cheese and everything is made fresh.
Having said that, depending on who is working the kitchen, the pizza/calzone only ranges can range from merely good to AWESOME -- Of course, their "merely good" is still better than the assembly-line shops.
My favorite is their calzone. We usually create our own. You can get up to 4 toppings or pay extra for more. They also have really reasonable lunch specials.
(NOTE: For some reason, I always think of the movie, "Mystic Pizza" when we order from here!)