We've tried this place twice to be fair and both times were surprisingly bad for such a popular place--it can't be the food that brings in the people. Poorly prepared with low quality ingredients, undercooked pizza, limp salads, and pasty garlic bread (where's the garlic?) were left uneaten, not just unfinished. Sorry, in this case two strikes and they're out. There are several better pizza places (take your pick) in Petaluma.
Pros: good location
Cons: bad food