Tried Alfy's today for the first time... All I can say is AcK! Nasty. A frozen Tombstone would have been 10 times better than Alfy's.
The sauce taste very strong like it had been in someones shoe for a long walk. The toppings were more or less tasteless as well as the crust. The few bites that the crust did have a taste it was of raw dough. Cheese? I can't comment on the cheese because they hardly put any on the pizzas.
The guy who took my order was nice, and the delivery guy was nice, but man can't live on niceness alone.
Don't get sucked into their cheap deals, spend the extra $$ and order from anywhere else. Or if you have to go cheap stick with the king of cheap pizza, Little Caesars.