This shop is quirky with a large range of item prices for the unpretentious shopper, someone interested in different things from the past. It has more vintage and country store and home goods than just decorative overpriced stuff you often find in antique shops. I found particularly interesting the vintage postcard collection they have (most about $1 or $2 each). It's definitely worth a stop and is just off the main road. They also have beer memorabilia.
Website is here: http://www.islandertradingpost.biz/