Country Maid is what country-road-side ice cream shops are all about. They have a HUGE selection of flavors, they make them on-site, and it tastes amazing. The price is very reasonable. There are benches out in the shade for eating your cones on. It gets VERY crowded on hot summer evenings, but I have never waited longer than 5 minutes for a cone!
They also sell homemade candies, and there is a seperate building behind it that sells the fruit of their orchards, which is also delicious. They are usually staffed by a bunch of high school kids, a new crop every season (just like the fruit!) but they are always friendly and seem to be having a good time.
Try the Honey ice cream, the Lemon sorbet, and the hot fudge sundaes!