For the two years that we were in Santa Cruz, Alex and I almost never failed to stop by Tony and Alba's whenever we were in Capitola. I still have memories of the zesty and tangy sauce mixing with the pepperoni slices. Ahh, a mini slice of heaven. There are so many great pizza places in the Santa Cruz area, and Tony and Alba's was at the top of our list.
If you're into some childish fun, you can also check out their mini arcade while you wait. But beware, the best games tend to have one broken joystick--at least that was the case while we were there.