I've only been here for drinks and appetizers in the little bar area. I enjoy the classic kitsch factor of this place. The view are great and parking is always easy. It's nice to go for a stroll around Shelter Island either before or after your meal. Yes, the mai tais are strong. They have a banquet room downstairs and it is popular for events. Definately worth checking out, if just for the mai tais. The pupu platter (hah ... I love to say that word) has a nice appetizer assortment that is perfect for sharing with a few people.