Crogan's is such a Montclair place. And that's a good thing. I stopped in one night after work and asked about their scotch selection. That led me through the stories of the bartender's golf and scotch tasting tour of Ireland. How cool! These guys know their stuff. A word to the wise... Stanford fans should probably stay away on game nights ;).
I haven't actually eaten dinner here, but the appetizers are typical bar fare. Nothing special, nothing wrong with it. Just a great place to stop in after work and have a drink or four.