It's all been said here: the beer selection rewards more sophisticated swillers and the burgers (in the one variety they offer) are terrific. Bar staff can be inattentive or just straight up rude (the last time we were there the only person taking orders was having difficulty juggling her job with an apparently vigorous text message debate). It's also often noisy and you need to arrive close to opening hours (or before) to get a table... this has improved somewhat since the Fire Department cracked down on them for overcrowding violations: now you wait outside to order instead of inside for a place to eat it.
I'd be happy to never go there again except there aren't that many bars that serve this kind of quality beers... for now it is good enough.
Pros: Beer and burgers are terrific
Cons: Service and atmosphere aren't.
more