Had not been to Oystercatchers since the renovation, came to celebrate our 29th anniversary. I entertain professionally at top restaurants around the country so I have high standards for $$$ restaurants. At the ""new"" Oystercatchers, I was not impressed. The HIP new interior feels more Manhattan than Tampa. Fortunately we opted for an outdoor table. For our dinner we shared six lifeless sampler oysters ($18) and followed that with the Paella for 2 ($52). Sadly the Paella arrived lukewarm showing signs of sitting around warming for hours lacking any of the steamy passion you expect in a good Paella.
Pros: Great Bayside Location
Cons: Lackluster expensive food and wine
more