UDF ice cream deserves the top ranking in Cincinnati based on two criteria. Flavor (many choices and excellent taste/texture) and price.
Unlike some other ice creams available in town, you can take the family to UDF and not have to take out a second mortgage to pay for it.
I have but one request, dump some of the cookie dough, left over candy bars and moose droppings to return to traditional ice creams, some of the stores don't even carry strawberry and/or chocolate chip anymore.
Pros: value (ice cream), convenient
Cons: "new" flavors, expense, lazy employees