I've been taking my car to Tom's Auto Repair (Honda Passport) for 4-5 years, and he's treated me well. Tom is very friendly, fixes the problems really quickly (rarely takes more than 1 day for any big job), and charges much less than the dealerships. I don't know if he charges less than other mechanics, but for the service, honesty, and reliability, I always go to him.
Pros: Honesty, Service, Friendliness, cost
Cons: N/A
more