The Fifth Avenue Center, now located on Broadway - but don't let that confuse you - offers personal counseling and psychotherapy for patients with problems ranging from stress to substance abuse to more serious mental illness.
In the 4 years that I've gone there I've had 3 therapists (due to my scheduling changes), and all three of them, even with varying levels of experience, were great. The offices are a little bland, due to them being shared by the entire staff, but the counselors do what they can with prints and plants, and it's what goes on in the offices that really matters anyway.
There's also a psychopharmacologist on staff who you can meet with separately to discuss medication.
Prices are charged on a sliding scale (I paid $50 per session), and most insurance plans are accepted, including Medicare and Medicaid.