Pass by all those touristy seafood places that are packed on City Island. Go where the locals go -- to The Black Whale! If you want a less expensive meal, go to the City Isalnd Diner. If you want a fancier place, go to Le Refuge. But if you want good food at a relaxed local spot, the Black Whale can't be beat! The outside dining area out back is perfect during the hot summer. And they have movie nights, too! Go there!
Pros: Excellent food, Not touristy
Cons: , Service can be spotty