JavaScript is not enabled.
The Castle Tavern & Marina - 6 Reviews - 13 Castle Court, Sterling Forest, NY - Bars, Pubs & Clubs Reviews - Phone (845) 477-3000

The Castle Tavern & Marina

Claim
marker
13 Castle Court
Sterling Forest, NY 10979
marker
(845) 477-3000
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Bars, Pubs & Clubs

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews

( 2 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 3 )

Best

So the rumor is that this place burned down back in the early 1900s and that the spirits of the people who died in that fire haunt the place to this day. Well I can't speak for...

Worst

First and last time here. Wow what an experience. 4 ?meals? for $62. Save your money and go to McDonalds. Fried clam platter is not a platter nor fried. This was a basket of a mi...

Our of the Ashes... 6/30/2010

So the rumor is that this place burned down back in the early 1900s and that the spirits of the people who died in that fire haunt the place to this day. Well I can't speak for that, but I can say that I've been there twice now since the new owners came in and I have loved the food both times. The first time I went, I was given the schpeel on how the new guys are working diligently to raise the level of service and fix the place up. Turns out they weren't full of BS. I liked it well that first time and even better the second. The menu had gotten bigger and the wait staff handled me much better. It's the best view on the lake and now it's becoming the best food too. I'll keep going back. Pros: Top Notch Entrees, Great Staff Cons: Old Building Still Being Buffed Up more

Great placeee 2/10/2010

the new management team of 2010 has really turned this place around!!! GREATTT food and cleaner than ever!! Check it out, definitely going to get its old name back Pros: amazinggg food! GReat lake view! more

coming 2009 3/12/2009

Hi, my name is Mike.People know us as Mike and Tony from the castle 2005-2007.I 100% agree with the reviews.We have retaken the castle stay tuned for 2009 . more

Sad to hear this 1/22/2009

Sorry to here the Castle has come to this. You of course are right it was a great place. I haven't been there for about 30 years.\r \r Freddie are you the Freddie who worked at the Castle when I (Lance) worked there as a bartender in the late 50's ? Apparently they will not let me include my email address so google me (Lance Schweizer) more

losy food oily food no charm butts an beer only 1/10/2009

nothing like it used to be ,,a family place, good food,now just a joke for drunks horres a place of sin.in the the old days a lot of famus people went there movie stars, babe ruth, other yankies, broklin dogers ,new york giants,gansters of old,famos people of of the the 20s 30s 40s went there , not like the thrash like today who only want to to get lad or drunk,,people dont even dont know the castle burn,t down 2 times people died in the fire and that the castle is haunted (i am not joking) i grew up in the castle as a littile boy.my grand mothers ghosht is still in the back room off the kithchen, and john smithmts is still in the basement at his work desk ,plus late at nite when no lights are on on the dance floor you can hear music and hear talking and music going. that will make a growen man pe his pants...start baking fish get rid of ,real ,not hambergers,hand cut ffs,real cole slaw, get some class ,dont go so dame cheap you have the money ,you have lots of it ,cheap o,,,,,,,,,,,, Pros: a lot of trashie people Cons: alot of trashie people more

Lakeside dining with bad music 7/26/2008

First and last time here. Wow what an experience. 4 ?meals? for $62. Save your money and go to McDonalds. Fried clam platter is not a platter nor fried. This was a basket of a miniscule portion of oil drenched little dough nuggets with a clam flavor served over oil drenched home cut fries. Howard Johnson?s would have been 20 star compared to this. $10.95. BBQ rib-rack was 7 country ribs that came out of vacuum wrapper heated up and commercial sauce poured over it. How they call them their famous ribs is a wonder to me. Country fried chicken was 3 pieces of oil drenched breaded chicken the size of a NY city pigeon. $9.95. Fish n?chips I just never have seen square fish and oil drenched fries. Oh, the box wine is well?.. box wine. If you must have lakeside dining stick with the bottled beer and their burgers. Pros: Lakeside Dining - cold bottled beer - Marina Cons: Needs a new cook - Oil cold everything served dripping oil more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for The Castle Tavern & Marina




HOLIDAY SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 3/1/2019

Editorial

  • Located on the Greenwood Lake, the Castle has activities and games, food and drinks. Open year round.

  • 11/16/2006 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Payments:

    American Express, Master Card, Visa
badge