The Bagelry has possibly the worst bagels ever- they taste like flavored little rocks! The flavors are very good though with varieties like vegetable, pesto, and typical flavors. There aren't any other places to go for freshly made bagels in Potsdam- so the Bagelry will stay in business with it's yucky bagels for many years to come. The toppings however are very good- the cream cheese is fresh and they have many other creative sandwiches like hummus or "the gobble"- turkey and russian dressing. They are also dirt cheap! So if you don't mind the horrid texture of your bagel, this could be an excellent place to go for a cheap lunch or late night meal.