Given the lovely location, the outdoor hardwood grill, and moderate prices, one might expect at least the kind of simply-prepared, but fresh and vibrant dishes that a careful, modest home cook might prepare: moist chicken with crisp brown skin, top-quality ingredients, etc. Unfortunately, the SheepMeadow Cafe does not deliver. The chicken is hideously salty and obviously cooked prior to being reheated on the grill, the salad leaves are brown around the edges and doused in poor-quality oil. Even the bread and butter are terrible. How about some loaves from Balthazar or Tom Cat, guys? Why is the butter filled with chives? If they clean up their act, this place would be lovely, but it is quite a disappointment in its present state.
Cons: Food, Price