The first time I had Indian food was at Shalimar Restaurant, and oh, what delicious food they have! They have a warm atmosphere with pretty decor, and as soon as you walk in, you'll smell all the delicious smells cooking up. I absolutely LOVE the Chicken Masala, although I'm sure it's really fattening (it has a lot of cream and sugar). I also love their eggplant dishes, and of course, their naan. I also recommend their mango lassis (sp?) which are absolutely delicious (and a great way to relieve your mouth of the spicy food you had).
P.S. Make sure that you really like Indian food, because after even just looking around in Shalimar, you WILL come out smelling like curry. :)