I'm honestly surprised at the bad reviews I've read. Don't know if we just got lucky or what, but a work crowd went for lunch yesterday and we really loved it. 3 of us had the pizza and we all thought it was outstanding (and I am a stickler for good pizza, won't touch Pizza Hut, Inn, or any of the chain delivery places). 2 had pasta dishes they said were very good, and 1 had the eggplant parmesan - he admitted he'd had better, but he still liked it. The garlic rolls are to die for (but brother, you'd better LOVE garlic), and everyone especially loved the house salad with the delicious house viniagrette. YUMMY!
We went to the Uptown location, which is a fun part of town for people watching.
Our one complaint has been said in other reviews - the service, while very friendly, left a lot to be desired. It was at least 15 minutes before we got our ordered drinks, another 10 or 15 before orders were taken, and it took forever to get our checks. What should have been an hour lunch took nearly 90 minutes.
As I said, maybe we just got lucky (and if that's the case, I'll come here and say so), but we loved the food and location (tiny but charming), and will definitely go back.
Pros: Excellent food, very reasonable prices
Cons: Very slow service