JavaScript is not enabled.
Pizza Rustica - 9 Reviews - 3913 N Sheridan Rd, Chicago, IL 60613, Chicago, IL - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (773) 404-8955

Pizza Rustica

Claim
marker
3913 N Sheridan Rd, Chicago, IL 60613
Chicago, IL 60613
marker
(773) 404-8955
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

Pizza Rustica - Chicago, IL
Pizza Rustica - Chicago, IL
Pizza Rustica - Chicago, IL
Pizza Rustica - Chicago, IL

Reviews

( 6 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 2 )
( 0 )

Best

Eaten here many times. Each time I leave happy and contented. BYOB helps. Relaxed atmosphere so if the place is busy don't expect to get in and out fast. My favorites. 1) ...

Worst

The pizza's not bad, but the paninis are pretty awful. The delivery service has messed up my order on at...

Great Atmosphere, Great Food 11/6/2010

Eaten here many times. Each time I leave happy and contented. BYOB helps. Relaxed atmosphere so if the place is busy don't expect to get in and out fast. My favorites. 1) the meatballs with any of the pasta , 2) if spare ribs with a pasta are on the special, get it. I dream about the spareribs. 3)pastas with cream sauces especially special raviolis like artichoke or squash, again sometimes on special and 4) any of the pizzas. Every time I go there I vow not to overeat, I fail every time. There is no pretension to the wait staff, just nice people. more

Editorial review from GrubHub 9/30/2008

by Scot at GrubHub Provided by GrubHub
Not so good. The crust was hard and very little cheese that was well done. The term Rustic does describe it well and I would not order again. more

The pizza's not bad, but the paninis are pretty awful. T... 6/11/2007

The pizza's not bad, but the paninis are pretty awful. The delivery service has messed up my order on at... more

The pizza's not bad, but the paninis are pretty awful. T... 6/11/2007

Caroline Provided by Partner
The pizza's not bad, but the paninis are pretty awful. The delivery service has messed up my order on at least 2 occasions. It's a cute place to ... more

Nice BYOB, better pizza elsewhere 11/21/2006

Quaint place on the Sheridan BYOB stretch, not a big fan of the pizza though. The crust is very thick, was overcooked and bordering on burned around the edges, and COMPLETELY overpowered the toppings that were on the pizza. The crust had a very smoky flavor and was crunchy which just didn't work for me. It might be worth a second shot given that I live in the neighborhood but for now I still go to D.O.C. or others. Pros: Nice neighborhood space, BYOB Cons: Pizza isn't my favorite more

The best thin crust in the city! 10/23/2006

I have been to this place several times and my friends are impressed when I take them. They rave about the flavors of the food! Pasta is delicious and authentic. If you are into pizza that boasts a thin crust and crisp then you will love this. Comfort food on a very intimate scale (not a large place), but an outstanding value for your buck! Pros: great value Cons: can be a bit crowded since it is rather small more

Great Pasta and Pizza!! 7/24/2006

I love this place. It's small and quaint. The food is phenominal! It's real Italian food cooked by an Italian. My one and only complaint is that there is not enough wait waitstaff. There are only 2 waitresses and no bus boys. You generally have to wait a while for anything. But if you have an evening with time to spare this place is AWESOME! Pros: Great food and prices Cons: Small waitstaff more

Great toppings & portion sizes! 7/13/2006

I can never bring myself to try the pasta here - even though I'm sure it's quite good - because the pizza is just out of this world! Crispy yet chewy in places crust perfectly supports whatever toppings you choose - they have everything from traditional pepperoni to olives and artichoke hearts. You can get individual pieces or a whole pie, and the prices are great. Service is fast & friendly. A great little find near the red Sheridan El stop! Pros: Delicious, intimate dining, great value more

Great Pizza! 9/22/2005

The pizza at this place is awesome especially if you like thin crust. The decor is nice and the staff is very friendly. It was a wonderful dining out experience. more

Fabulous Food & People!! 8/1/2005

We love this new authentic little establishment!! The pizzas are very tasty and fresh ingredients make them superior to other neighborhood spots. But...it's the pasta that's incredible. Many types to choose from and I was taken with the homemade meatballs - they taste so fresh and real, like they were made right then by an Italian grandmother with her secret recipe. The daily specials are exciting, too. Overall, it's a great dining experience!! Pros: accommodating, friendly, authentic more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Pizza Rustica




SPRING SALE!!!:
20% OFF all yearly plans
Use spring at checkout. Expires 6/30/2018

Editorial

  • In Short
    Among other restaurants along the lively Sheridan strip, this storefront draws attention for the smells alone. Faux terra cotta walls are as far as decoration goes in the tight...

  • 7/25/2005 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Monday 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM Tuesday Closed Wednesday 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM Thursday 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM Friday 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM Saturday 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM Sunday 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Payments:

    American Express, Master Card, Visa
  • Neighborhoods:

    Lakeview, North Side
badge