Pets & Stuff offers an assortment of equipment and supplies for all kinds of pets, selling a number of animals themselves. Although they sometimes have cats and dogs, they seem to specialize in the more exotic: Fresh and salt water fish, birds, small mammals, and reptiles. The staff seems knowledgeable about the different offerings, and their small building is jam packed with acquariums, cages, food, and more. My kids love to go there to just look around.
About the only negative for me is that the place smells, well, like lots of pets! ;-)