I am not into reptiles personally, but I had a friend who was. And he swore by Parma Pets for everything he needed. I've been to the store on numerous occasions, and it's always intereresting.
Reptiles of all types are on display and for sale. The store also carries a lot of used aquariums for reptile homes. The staff is friendly, and they know EVERYTHING about reptiles. If you get them started, you'll be there for a while.
This store has been around since the early seventies, and they pride themselves on their history and being a reputable dealer of reptiles and reptile products.
They also have a selection of small furry animals, but I think they're mostly purchased as reptile food.