I can't judge the food from only one visit there - my dinner companions raved about it, I felt like it was mediocre. But the comfortable, casual environment plus the great live bands made it all worthwhile. Because of the music & location, I'll give it a 4, if it was only rated on food I'd have to give it a 2.5 only.
Keep the music and improve the food - its a great location.
Pros: Great live music!
Cons: Food - just down the middle