JavaScript is not enabled.
Oteri's Italian Pastries - 2 Reviews - 4919 N 5th St, Philadelphia, PA - Wedding Cakes Reviews - Phone (215) 457-4958

Oteri's Italian Pastries

4919 N 5th St (at Check out all THREE Locations!)
Philadelphia, PA 19120
(215) 457-4958
Incorrect info? Correct your listing


Oteri's Italian Pastries - Philadelphia, PA
Oteri's Italian Pastries - Philadelphia, PA
Oteri's Italian Pastries - Philadelphia, PA
Oteri's Italian Pastries - Philadelphia, PA
Oteri's Italian Pastries - Philadelphia, PA


( 2 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )




All reviews seem positive

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/18/2013

You made a cake for my sister's bridal shower. I took some to work, and everyone wanted to know where I got it made. Definitely promoted your business. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 10/28/2013

OTERI'S Bakery has the best Butter Cake, Cinnamin Buns and decorated birthday and other events cakes.\r \r IF you liek Butter Cake, there is no place around that makes such a delicious, fattening, and ""Off-your-diet"" delight. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 10/11/2013

Oteri's cannoli's are the best. Had some Saturday night at my AUnt Eileen's 70th Birthday Party. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 9/20/2013

Oteri's on 5th street thank you our cakes was amazing more

Editorial review from Citysearch 9/4/2013

Oteri's Bakery made my Beautiful and delicious Sweet 16 cake many years ago. Im so happy my friend's family business is still making beautiful cakes and happy memories! more

Editorial review from Citysearch 8/20/2013

Thank you for the great service, it was our first visit and we loved everything we tried but the service was the best part. Our children LOVED it there. We will be back very soon:) Thank you more

Editorial review from Citysearch 8/2/2013

Oteris bakery thank you so much our cake was amazing ... more

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/25/2013

Oteri's has the best Italian Rum cake. We ordered one for our office birthday party. We all decided this would be the cake we will order every month. DELICIOUS. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/10/2013

They are the best at what they do. I have been getting my birthday cakes from them every year for the past seven years. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 5/15/2013

Well, Oteri's is neither dirty nor is it attached to a jewelry store (not for about five years now). They've since taken out the jewelry store and expanded the bakery, putting in a gelato section that is, like everything else in this store, heavenly. They have an assortment of both Italian and Spanish cakes and pastries. Italian creme cake can be found alongside flan, tembleque, and German chocolate cake. Granted, the neighborhood is a war zone and parking is precarious at best. They have a tiny parking lot on the left-hand side of the bakery, but enter and exit at your own risk. But the aggravation is worth it for some heavenly treats - and some of which you can get last-minute (if you're in a crunch for a birthday cake that's great-tasting and cheap, too). more

Editorial review from Citysearch 5/13/2013

I can't believe I hadn't reviewed this place before. I get my cakes for all family events and birthdays from Oteri's bakery. They never let me down and never cease to amaze me. They have pre-made designed cakes for those last minute purchases or you could order ahead of time and get the cake just how you like it the day of the event. You could pick one of their designs, switch up their designs, or bring in a copy of your invitations or a photo and have it scanned onto the cake. The cakes are reasonably priced and come in different sizes. I normally get their regular sheet cake and never hear any complaints. It tastes so good! I've had cakes with too much icing which make the cake too sweet. Oteri's does it right. ;) They also sell cookies, cupcakes and pies all specially decorated for different occasions. They sell piñatas and bday candles too. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 5/9/2013

I have bought several cakes from Oteris, and I always have a plesant experience. Great customer service, unique and delicous tasting cakes, and convenient hours. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 5/7/2013

I actually heard of Oteri's via Facebook because of a debate over the best bakery in Philly between Oteri's and another well known bakery. A friend of mine needed a cake for a one year old's birthday and this place was recommended. The cake was sooooooo good. They did a character cake (I forgot the of the newer ones) on a sheet cake and then had the baby's name on huge baby blocks. It was the most adorable cake ever. It was also complimented a lot. The sheet cake was vanilla while the blocks were pound cake. It was so good. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 5/3/2013

Great Bakery. They do fondant cakes. I took a picture to them of a fondant cake from the Cake Boss and they did the cake (alot Cheaper) and tasted great. I was amazed of the cakes people were picking up. It was very busy. I saw a Pepsi Bottle, Juicy Coutoure bag and some x-rated cakes. I also had a connoli when I was there it was the best one I ever had. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 3/22/2013

My cake was EXTREMLY beautiful and tasted fantastic!! I HIGHLY recommend this company to every bride that wants their cake to be the talk of their fabulous wedding! more

Editorial review from Citysearch 3/20/2013

Absolutely love my cake. Beautiful design and presentation. I can even get my daughter's birthday cake from here. Last minute is not a problem. Love their Service. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 3/18/2013

I loved my wedding cake,my guest also did. The look was wonderful, and the taste was great. Can't wait until my 1year anniversary for my froozen treat!! more

Editorial review from Citysearch 3/14/2013

The cake was beautiful!!! I was so pleased, and all the guests at my wedding raved about how good it was... I highly recommend them, my cake look just like the picture i showed them. Irene was very nice and although the bakery itself was very crowded with customers, the service was fast. We are planning to renew our vows in 10 years, and I will definitely be getting my cake from Oteri's again! more

Editorial review from Citysearch 1/11/2013

I have been buying Oteri's rum cakes for about 50 years. Years ago I shopped at their Broad st store after that closed I have been going to the 5th street store. Always satisfied. Yes they do make the best rum cakes. I have been happy with all the variety of cakes from there. The connolis are great too. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 12/19/2012

your cakes are a work of art. Next special occasion, I will be calling you. Keep up the great work!! more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for Oteri's Italian Pastries

15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 3/1/2019

Have more time to enjoy the moment by letting us provide that special unique cake for your next birthday.

Owner Message

  • Oteri's Bakery has been family owned since 1904!

    Over a century of providing the best in quality baked goods to Philadelphia! During these years we've had the pleasure of servicing multiple generations of weddings... and look to provide the needs of the next generation!


    Oteris Italian Bakery specializes in creating custom designed cakes and trays for any occasion. We create ice-cream cakes, cakes with exotic flavors and fillings, and wedding cakes with multiple tiers and layers. We arrange party trays with delicious assortments of cookies and pastries. Our computerized photo cakes have become quite popular! Bring in a photo and watch us work our magic. For those who wait until the last minute, we stock a delicious variety of birthday cakes, dash in, and well set you up in no time!. * Cakes
    * Wedding,Birthday,or any Occasion!
    * Large Selection of Wedding Cakes
    * Ice-Cream Cakes
    * Italian & Butter Cookie Trays
    * Cannolis & Miniature Party Trays
    * French Pastries
    * New York Cheesecake
    * We Service
    * Hotels
    * Catering Companies
    * Country Clubs
    * Restaurants
    * Organizations & Institutions
    * Discounts Offered
    * Delivery Available
    * Wholesale & Retail

    4919 N 5th Street
    Phila,PA 19120 215-457-4958

    6323 Woodland Ave
    Phila,PA 215-724-0793

    4023 Fairdale St
    Phila,PA 215-637-1330

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon-Sat 8am-9pm ; Sun 8am-7pm ; Open 7 Days
  • Payments:

    American Express, Discover, Master Card, Visa
  • Neighborhoods:

    North Philadelphia, Olney