Wow! My family and I ate here for the first time and we will be going back regularly. My husband had the Chicken Marsala, which I tried, it was out of this world. Our server informed us it's made to order and you can definitely tell it is. My kids and I shared a pizza and it was insanely good. The bottom of the pizza was cooked to a golden brown and you could tell the sauce is homemade. We had the cheesecake and tiramisu for dessert......hands down, the best cheesecake I've had in a long time. It was not heavy at all. The hostess greeted us with a friendly smile and our server was always there when we needed him. It was also very clean inside, which is a must when I dine out. We will make NY 54 a regular weekly experience since we live so close and have been looking for an authentic restaurant.