Nic's restaurant is excellent! The prices are a little high for the area, but the food is awesome. Nic's is owned by the same people that own the Haunted Hamburger in Jerome. One of my favorite things at Nic's is the fresh, warm bread and olive oil dip that they serve you prior to the main course.
They are located in Old Town Cottonwood, just down the street from The Outsiders. If you like Italian food, stop by and visit, you'll love the food, and the atmosphere is great too.
By the way, the name is Nic's, not Nick's.