JavaScript is not enabled.
My Tomato Pie Inc - 16 Reviews - 3085 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (716) 838-0969
top 10

My Tomato Pie Inc

3085 Sheridan Dr
Amherst, NY 14226
(716) 838-0969
Incorrect info? Correct your listing


( 9 )
( 4 )
( 2 )
( 1 )
( 0 )


A welcoming atmosphere with a Mom and Pop feel. Pros: Home made foccacia, light pizza's and peanut butter pies.


My visit to this restaurant wasn't too bad. The pizza bread was great! Wouldn't recommend ordering the chicken parm dinner though, my chicken came out pink and I just cannot eat...

Thank You. 4/26/2007

As the owner of My Tomato Pie, I would like to thank all my customers who have supported us over the last nine years. It is you that have made us one of Buffalo’s #1 Independently Owned Restaurants. Without you, our excellent homemade food would only be enjoyed by friends and family who have kept these recipes secret for generations and generations. I have been lucky enough to prepare many very special meals for you and your families. As many of my family recipes’ have been used for your special meals in the restaurant, our banquet rooms, or possibly catered right at your house. As I continue to serve your family, your friends, and you, please show your support by giving us feedback. Let me know if you ever want me to run a special that you might be craving, or even tell me if we could have been a little better. Our menu has developed through the years because of your feedback, so please keep it coming. Thanks, Anthony more

No image

Good 4/14/2006

This place is very good. I’m a big fan of everything on the menu. This place is more than pizza, even though they have many options and they all taste great. They have some very good sandwiches on the menu here. The prices are great and the food tastes good. If you are in Amherst you should stop by. more

No image

My Tomato Pie 4/2/2006

This is a nice little place with a big menu. You can find this restaurant off Sheridan drive, tucked away in the North Town Plaza. They make a wide array of pizzas. All the pizzas I’ve had here are great but they also have other great items on their menu. The service is sometimes slow but the prices are very reasonable. more

No image

More than just pizza 3/28/2006

This place is more than just pizza. They also have great salads, wraps, subs and sandwiches. Everything I’ve had has been very well prepared. My favorite though has been their banana peppers appetizers. They actually are the best banana peppers I’ve ever tasted. This is a wonderful restaurant in Amherst. more

Best Italian Food 8/15/2005

This is one of the best Italian places with a wide variety of dishes to choose from. The prices are also really great. They have really good pizza, chicken parm and other dishes. The best part of this place is the calzone. It is awesome. They also have the frequent diner program which saves you even more money if you eat there more often. more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for My Tomato Pie Inc

50% OFF all yearly plans
Use HOLIDAY at checkout. Expires 12/29/2017


  • Gourmet pizza, pasta, focaccia sandwiches, homemade desserts and fried green tomatoes, plus beer and wine.

  • 10/2/2006 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon. - Thu., Sun. 11am - 9:30pm;Fri. - Sat. 11am - 10:30pm
  • Payments:

    Visa, Discover, American Express, Master Card, Cash