Michie Tavern offers a fun experience, but the food is not the tastiest option. Also, it is fairly expensive ($15/person for lunch). The restaurant is located in an actual 18th Century tavern, and the staff is in period dress. The kitchen uses recipes from the 18th Century, and the food is served on tin plates (and drinks in tin cups). The experience is very fun and worth it, but it would be a one-time visit. We did not visit the attached store or tour the inn, which might have added to our experience.
http://www.michietavern.com/
more