JavaScript is not enabled.
McFadden's- Closed - 2 Reviews - 1576 North High Street, Columbus, OH - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (614) 294-2200

McFadden's- Closed

1576 North High Street
Columbus, OH 43201
(614) 294-2200
Incorrect info? Correct your listing


( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 1 )


All reviews seem negative


Great college gathering . However, One bad apple rotens the bunch.The wns bathroom is 6 people in line, Dirty, Gross. -No line in mens-MeanwhileMuscleguy yells at girls for using ...


To that person that wrote about some ""manager on duty"" that is threatening and rude...I know EXACTLY who you are talking about. I made the huge mistake of planning my Bachlorette party at Mcfaddens in Columbus and that is supposed to be a once in a lifetime moment and it turned out to be worst in my lifetime....I decided to book with Mcfaddens because on their website they claimed you paid $10 a person for this VIP ROOM and all of your friends got cheap drinks and a free bottle of champagne and shout outs from DJ, make your own shots, and bridal gift bags....the only thing they gave me was the room....I had to talk party planner into throwing the bottle of champagne because that's what the website promised. When I got to the bar, they wouldn't give me the champagne I had to look up my email and show him it had been authorized. The VIP room had no lights whatsoever...pitch black....drink cups spilled everywhere....half eaten plates with food on the table and people constantly hanging out in there and not leaving. I told this ""manager"" about my situation and he said lucky for me your cards are on file and I am going to charge you anyways. He didn't even say Im sorry but unfortunately it has to be this way....NO apology from him. He also used threats and said he was going to call security even though I was making a reasonable complaint.....Also, the bathrooms were so disgusting I felt dirty washing my hands in there. The bathroom doors were all hanging by a corner and someone I didn't even know had to hold it for me while I went. ALL of the doors were like this. I had never been to McFadden's before and I wish I hadn't. They couldn't even offer friendly service or at least deacent service for someone celebrating such a big moment in their life. This is not just me wanting to vent....I don't want other people to make the same mistake I made.....I would not plan any party there and the staff is so rude I wouldn't even reccomend going. They ended up charging my sister for the room without telling her even thuogh she was not the person that had the money. They also charged her for things she didnt get and wouldn't drink. If you hang out in the Campus gateway.....all of the surrounding bars are WAY better than this place. Pros: I don't have to go back there ever again! Cons: Horrible service....Dirty atmosphere...BR=gross more

Your Ego is NOT ur amigo!!!! Treat ur customers right.they 5/10/2010

Great college gathering . However, One bad apple rotens the bunch.The wns bathroom is 6 people in line, Dirty, Gross. -No line in mens-MeanwhileMuscleguy yells at girls for using b'rm. says He is mangr ('Offdty'). Is Threatning & RUDE! He is drinking BEER off duty.You r lucky YOU have a JOB.!!! treat ur customers w/Respect! more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for McFadden's- Closed

15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 11/30/2017

Owner Message

  • McFadden's is the most dynamic establishment in Columbus - Offering lunch and dinner, crazy nightlife or an exciting place to watch a sports game, the many facets of McFadden's will never disappoint you or let you leave with out a smile! Whether it is the original McFadden's located in New York City just minutes from Time Square or the latest McFadden's located on the corner of State and Rush in Chicago, McFadden's has come to be known as one of the nation's premier bar/restaurants.

    McFadden's Columbus is the hottest new addition to the South Campus Gateway. If you are looking for a premier nightspot to party as a couple, as a single or as a group of friends, McFadden's will always be the perfect place to have a great time. With the cities best DJs, nuttiest bartenders and courteous staff, you will experience the best service and wake up the next morning craving to come back!

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Daily 11am - 2:30am
  • Payments:

    American Express, Master Card, Visa
  • Neighborhoods:

    University District, Weinland Park, South Campus