My wife has been looking for New York pizza since she moved here 15 years ago - and the first time I went home with her to NY she took me for pizza just to 1) show me what she meant and 2) prove NY pizza was better. We keep going back to Maria's for the pizza, it's the closest to her ideal we've found, and that's saying a lot. Great selection of topings, overall a great pie to take out. Eating in is small and homey, staff and service always friendly and efficient.
Pros: Food and service
Cons: Not the location for a romantic dinner (after all, it's pizza and pasta!)