I give them five stars with the understanding that it is for the narrow scope of what they do, and so I don't hold it against them that they are not all things to all vintage jewelry people. With that being said, far and away the best place in town to drop five figures on an antique engagement ring. Dazzling selection and wonderful staff. I dressed down in my running clothes and had days of scruff on the off chance I decided to buy on my visit (for bargaining purposes, I didn't want to look like I had a lot of money to spend). Nevertheless, they treated me like an old, faithful client. We had an excellent discussion on antique jewelry and old techniques of cutting stones, and I learned quite a bit! Definitely will keep them in my future shopping plans.