JavaScript is not enabled.
Margaritaville Cafe - 8 Reviews - 500 Duval St., Key West, FL - Gift Shops Reviews - Phone (305) 292-1435

Margaritaville Cafe

500 Duval St.
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 292-1435
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Related categories:

Food & Dining , Retail Shopping


( 0 )
( 5 )
( 3 )
( 0 )
( 0 )


The perfect place to return to...Margaritaville Cafe. You don't have to be a Parrothead to enjoy the second-to-none Cheeseburger in Paradise or the multitude of margarita flavors....


All reviews seem positive

Editorial review from Citysearch 9/7/2013

Clean, great food, standard pricing, not cheapy, relaxed but nice atmosphere. Seafood mac and cheese was delicious! more

a cockhroach crawled out of my daughter's burger 3/5/2007

the server was nice enough, but when the food came, my daughter went to put the lettuce on her burger and a huge cockhroach darted across her plate onto the table. of course they brought us new food and bought our lunch, but some of us were too disgusted to eat and everyone agreed that the burgers were not paradise and the other food was also subpar more

Mahi mahi was Paradise even if Hamburger wasn't 9/26/2005

We stopped for a quick, late dinner. Fast service, no wait (this was just after Rita, though, don't know the usual status). The fish sandwich was great. Super fresh, very nice. The burger wasn't as good as expected, but not bad, either. I ""upgraded"" to the Uptown margarita. Not sure if it was worth the extra cost, either, since I didn't have a basic one. It was a bit noisy -- if you like quiet conversation it may not happen Pros: Location, Fairly Inexpensive, Fresh fish Cons: Noisy more

Pretty darn good 8/1/2005

Went with a group of 8 on our trip a few days ago. Lots of cheeseburgers at the table, but some of us were much more adventerous with appetizers and meals. Fairly good all around, not a 10, probably an 8 or 9. If you like a place you can hear above the music skip it. Very loud. Make sure you get there before 10 PM if you want to eat, they have a limited menu after 10 PM Pros: Food Quality Cons: Loud more

Margaritaville Cafe 10/2/2004

After eating at the one in Orlando I was dissapointed in the Key West restaurant. Menu was limited and food wasn't bad but average. A lot of fried stuff. A good place to grab a bite if you are in a hurry. The service was fast and friendly. Clean and comfortable. Pros: affordable, convienant more

Parrotheadville 12/22/2002

Stop in a experiance parrotheadville, a great place to duck out of the heat on Duvall street and grab a Cheeseburger in Paradise and the libation of your choice. more

Welcome Parrotheads! 11/25/2002

Loved it! Totally Jimmy Buffet. Great atmosphere. Wonderful carribean food! Inexpensive. Right on Duval street in the heart of Key West. Truly worth it! more

Waste Away...Again! 8/8/2002

The perfect place to return to...Margaritaville Cafe. You don't have to be a Parrothead to enjoy the second-to-none Cheeseburger in Paradise or the multitude of margarita flavors. Eat downstairs or up and enjoy live music (even Jimmy Buffett himself on occasion). Right smack in the middle of Duval Street excitement is the original and best Margaritaville Cafe! Pros: Taste, Variety Cons: Service more

All Buffet, all the time... 5/23/2002

If you're a Jimmy Buffet fan, this is a must. Pretty standard food/drinks at reasonable prices, but they have live music, fun atmosphere, and when a band isn't playing they play Buffet over the speakers. Worth a stop into the attached store as well. Pros: fun atmosphere Cons: marginal food more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Margaritaville Cafe

50% OFF all yearly plans
Use HOLIDAY at checkout. Expires 12/29/2017

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon. - Sat. 10am - 2am;Sun. 11am - 12pm
  • Payments:

    Visa, American Express, Master Card