JavaScript is not enabled.
LYLES JEWELRY & COIN - 5 Reviews - 4 Public Square, Medina, OH - Jewelry Reviews - Phone (330) 722-4243


4 Public Square
Medina, OH 44256
(330) 722-4243
Incorrect info? Correct your listing




( 2 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 3 )


I read these reviews and I am convinced that the negative ones are written by people who were having a bad day - (or felt their items were worth more .. when they weren't.) I...


Lyle's is the absolute WORST place for customer service. Lyle is EXTREMELY unfriendly and not helpful at all. He has the worst demeanor I have ever seen. He doesn't care about his...

Editorial review from Citysearch 8/31/2013

I have been doing business with Lyle and his wife for years. They have always been polite and courteous to me and the many others I have referred to the them over the past twenty years. They are by far the most knowledgeable experts on rare coins and rare items in the area. In fact I even joke with Lyle about being a guest on the TV show Pawn Stars, because he could easily be one of the expert guests that appear on the show sharing his wisdom and experience. Once again thanks, and keep up the great work, I'll be seeing you soon hopefully with some rare collectibles. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 8/28/2013

I have always enjoyed doing business with Lyle and his staff. They are very polite and willing to assist you with anything you may need. I have purchased several coins over the years and have always been happy with the transactions. Thanks Lyle. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/29/2013

I gave the place two chances. First time I went in to have him look at some silver I had. I wasn't sure if it was silver plated or silver. He looked at it and says ""junk"" and walked away beforw I could ask about buying silver. RUDE. I gave him another chance thinking maybe he was having a bad day then. I called and asked about buying scrap sterling silver. He tells me over the phone he sells it by the troy oz. I drive down and he changes his story. He says he sells it by ""lots"" and I'd have to buy 9.1 ounces of it. I asked why he didn't say that over the phone. He just says ""sorry, that's how all places sell it"" lie.\r I was ready to spend 100 there, not 181 and not to a misleading, rude owner. I don't know how people guve this guy decent reviews. Maybe theyre family. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 5/14/2013

This man is rude, unprofessional and dishonest. He does not pay fair price, preys on desperate people, and needs a serious course in manners and customer service. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 1/9/2013

lyle treated me well and paid a good price on my sterling silver more

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/27/2012

Dont sell anything here. I brought in 10.6 oz of .999 silver and was offered 220 dollars which was ""top dollar"". Laughed. Went to 650 gold in Brunswick (cost me 2 bucks in gas to get there and back) and they gave me 300 dollars without any haggle PLUS one oz fell out of my pocket in the car so they gave me a lot more money for less than what I tried to sell here. LOL more

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/14/2012

Great choices of jewelry for really good prices! more

Editorial review from Citysearch 10/22/2012

Excellent service and Lyle paid me a high price on my gold. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 6/28/2012

What an experience. I walked in not knowing how much my gold and coins were worth. Lyle and another guy talked to me and gave me great information about what i was selling and an offer to buy. Not knowing for sure i went to another place nearby and they were rude and the number they gave was far less than lyles. I went right back and sold my items there. I will tell all my friends and family that lyles is the place to go the medina area. Thanks, Shirl M. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 6/15/2012

I read these reviews and I am convinced that the negative ones are written by people who were having a bad day - (or felt their items were worth more .. when they weren't.) I did much homework - tested a few gold dealers in Cleveland, Strongsville, and Medina, and chose Lyles of Medina. On numerous occasions in 2012, I bought, sold, obtained appraisals (written and verbal) and transacted at least 10 times with Lyle ... and each time he was personable, kind, knowledgeable, fair, and professional. I always felt I received a fair deal from Lyle. I never met Lyle before this year - but after these 10 transactions I would recommend Lyles to anyone. Too bad the negative people do most of the blogging.. I suggest you take your items to a few dealers.. like i did.. and end up at Lyles... You will see what I mean. more

Lyles, a pleasure to do business with 2/28/2012

I've been doing business with Lyle for at least 15 years. Lyle is a good guy and fun to talk to. I'm surprised at the reviews. If you get to know Lyle you will change your mind. I have have NEVER felt ripped off by him. There are many other places to go to but I will stick with Lyle. more


Lyle's is the absolute WORST place for customer service. Lyle is EXTREMELY unfriendly and not helpful at all. He has the worst demeanor I have ever seen. He doesn't care about his customers AT ALL. He gives you the lowest price possible and rips you off. If you are looking to sell your jewelry, please go to LaPlaca, which is two doors down from Lyle's. I took two pairs of earrings and a necklace to Lyle's and he told me he would give me $30 TOTAL for them. I didn't take the offer and went to LaPlaca instead. LaPlaca offered me $115 for the same pieces of jewelry! It was amazing the price difference and definitely worth it to go two doors down!! I can't even say this place is worth one star. It was the absolute worst I have ever been treated in my life. I did sell him some of my jewelry and I regret it completely. I went back in only 15 minutes after the transaction, asked him if I could give him back the check he JUST wrote me and then I would take back my jewelry. He told me that they mark their stuff up DOUBLE what they give their customers for it and I would have to buy everything back for double the price. TERRIBLE business model. He has absolutely no compassion and does not care about his customers in the slightest. Please take my word for it and DO NOT go to Lyle's. Go two doors down to LaPlaca and you will get your money's worth AND have excellent customer service. more

horrible demeanor 12/14/2011

I just called to ask about appraisal services and was given abrupt one or two word answers about the availability of an appraiser and his hours. When I asked if there was a charge for the service he said 'sure' and when I asked what that charge would be he answered 'I don't know'. Really makes me want to go in with my valuables or ever do business with this company. more

Poor Service 3/11/2011

I went into the store to make a purchase but was not knowledgeable about the subject so I asked a lot of questions. The owner was rude and trying to hurry me out, I was shocked by his treatment. I left not believing what happened. Maybe got him on a bad day. more
< Previous 1 Next >
all yearly plans
Use BF2017 at checkout. Expires 11/28/2017

Owner Message

  • Serving Medina County For 30 Years "MEDINA'S BEST KEPT SECRET!" IN BUSINESS SINCE 1980. Lyles Jewelry & Coin in Medina, Ohio has a large inventory of gold, silver and estate jewelry at reasonable prices! Coin supplies, appraising, jewelry repair and layaway are available. Need cash now? Host a gold party and make hundreds of dollars. Have a girls night out and make money selling your unwanted gold. For more info call Hazel 330-722-4243 or visit our other site. Lyles Jewelry & Coin Buys And Sells: Gold, Silver, Diamonds, Platinum, Estate Jewelry, Coins, Type Coins, Coin Collections, Rare Coins, U.S. Paper Money, Sterling Silver Flatware & Plates, Costume Jewelry, Stamps & More!, Gold Class Rings, Silver Dollars & Arrowheads.

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Monday - Friday 10am to 6pm Saturday 10am to 3pm
  • Payments:

    Discover, Master Card, Visa