La Mia Pizza is both a neighborhood pizza spot is my personal pick for New York style pizza. They make a great variety of pies and will go the unusual route with successful results. Those would include their lasagna slice, which has a mix of ricotta and ground beef on the pie, as well as their ziti slice. Since ziti slices appear to be a New Jersey thing, it warms the heart to see it here in the city.
Just thinking about these pies makes me want to head right up there and order a slice now.