Each time we visit Marathon, we look for new places to dine that we haven't yet tried. We asked around to all of the locals regarding where to get the best Stone Crabs. Everyone said: ""You must go to the Key Fisheries"". If you are used to regular seating by a hostess, dressing up for dinner, etc., this will be a unique experience for you. It is such a relaxed environment and food is fantastic. We dined one evening on stone crabs and went back for lunch for the Lobster Rueben the next day. Then, we stopped in the fish store, attached to the eatery, and bought enough stone crabs for dinner. The staff was friendly and the customer service was terrific. I was impressed! I highly recommend the Key Fisheries as one of your stops on your next trip.
Pros: Relaxed environment, take all the time you want to dine.