JavaScript is not enabled.
Johnny Manhattan's - 29 Reviews - 3718 Hubertus Road, Hubertus, WI - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (262) 628-7700
top 10

Johnny Manhattan's

Claim
marker
3718 Hubertus Road
Hubertus, WI 53033
marker
(262) 628-7700
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews

( 22 )
( 1 )
( 2 )
( 1 )
( 3 )

Best

Awesome food! We can't get enough of Johnny Manhattan's food! The crab cakes are just delicious! Last time...

Worst

Too smoky... Bar smoke filters to dining area. Needs exhaust badly. See you in June 2010 when the smokefree law sets in.

AMAZING STEAKS! 10/26/2012

Awesome food! We can't get enough of Johnny Manhattan's food! The crab cakes are just delicious! Last time... more

AMAZING STEAKS! 10/26/2012

KathyMequon Provided by Partner
Awesome food! We can't get enough of Johnny Manhattan's food! The crab cakes are just delicious! Last time we ordered deep fried shrimp with crab c... more

Best place to eat love it tell all my 6/10/2012

Best place to eat love it tell all my friends. Love the filet soup and salad potatoes great friendly waitstaff. Clean restrooms. Must have escargot and crab cakes. Friend had prime rib. Let me tell you melted in his mouth great place to eat and drink. relaxing dont feel rushed. been to other places and waited 20 minutes for waitress to even take our drink order. Who needs two for one or coupons I dont. If i want a great meal Johnny Manhattens is my place!!!!!!! more

Perhaps I expected too much 5/13/2012

Cute enough place...doesn't make up for the lack of personality of staff and lack luster food. None of four... more

Perhaps I expected too much 5/13/2012

kareng4 Provided by Partner
Cute enough place...doesn't make up for the lack of personality of staff and lack luster food. None of four of us were impressed, although one cou... more

Not the place for a fish fry. 9/26/2011

We went for the Friday fish fry. We ordered a couple of drinks, the crab cakes and two fish fries. The server brings the drinks with the salad selections. Before we could taste the salads or sip our drinks another server dropped off the fish plates. Asked where the crab cakes were; they're coming. Low and below the answer for 'do the apps always come after the entrees' was 'its Friday'. The fish tasted like it was prepared earlier and warmed up. The crab cakes when they came were salty and not very good. So if you are into a RUSH job of getting you in and out with so so food by all means go there. We're not. Lots of good Fish Fry places out there so why waste your good hard earned money. more

If you like steak, you will love Johnny Manhattans 3/22/2011

We went on a Saturday night and the drive there was beautiful. It is a quaint little steak house in the Holy Hill area which is warm and inviting and cozy. Our waitress was exceptional and had us laughing all through dinner and all the way home. The dinner was perfectly prepared from the french onion soup, to the salad, to the best flavored steak one could imagine. One of our group had the baby back ribs which were so tender they fell off the bone. The place was packed so I would recommend making a reservation and then get ready for one of the best meals that you have ever had. The dress is casual and everything about the evening was classy but not pretentious. If you enjoy exceptional food and a relaxed and laid back atmosphere, this is the place for you. We will all be back - sooner than later. more

over rated ! 9/7/2010

1st off the owner was VERY friendly w/my date...would not even acknowledge me....HELLO...there are two of us! (rude) The salad average, crabcakes...below average, the crab mushroom soup...my advice....pass on this, it was more of a ""DIP"" than soup....mind you i do not like watered down soup, but this was not soup....would be great as an appetizer served w/crackers. We both agreed that the mashed potatoes were more of something you'd get from an ""Applebee's"" more

OMG Great Food 10/23/2009

OMG Ate there for the first time about 6 months ago and was very impressed with the food and the service was fantastic. Can't get a better steak anywhere. Priced right.........including soup & salad. We keep going back,once a week, we love it, recommend it to everyone. Pros: Great Steaks Cons: Parking occassionally more

Too smoky... 5/27/2009

Too smoky... Bar smoke filters to dining area. Needs exhaust badly. See you in June 2010 when the smokefree law sets in. more

Best Steak in a LONG TIME 5/8/2009

I had the pleasure of eating at Johnny Manhattan's this past month. I had a filet and it was honestly the... more

Best Steak in a LONG TIME 5/8/2009

legalgoddess Provided by Partner
I had the pleasure of eating at Johnny Manhattan's this past month. I had a filet and it was honestly the best steak I have had in a long, long ti... more

You won't leave hungry. 11/22/2008

We've been there several times and have always had a great meal. Friday nights can be very busy so we pass on that evening. My husband always orders the steaks and they're de-lish. Bar is a bit smokey for me. more

not so Manhattan Johnny!! 11/10/2008

I was recently in Hubertus and stumbled across this gem. Gem not so much. We were greeted by the hostess who seemed frazzled. The atmosphere was of a beat down supper club. My gut told me to walk out however, we stayed. Big mistake we both had the Friday night fish fry. It tasted like the fish was fried hours prior then reheated in the microwave. The server was friendly. The kicker was when it came time to pay we were told by the server that we could't pay on separate charges. That the owner did not allow this. Come to find out the owner was the ""frazzeled"" hostess. Unbelievable! Next time I will go with my gut feeling and run! Pros: Holy Hill is close by. more

supperclub revival at its best! 9/29/2008

an early 70's supperclub feel with intimate seating,wonderful antique back-bar,and a very friendly... more

supperclub revival at its best! 9/29/2008

mrsmick Provided by Partner
an early 70's supperclub feel with intimate seating,wonderful antique back-bar,and a very friendly waitstaff made this my favorite steak house,one ... more

BEST STEAK EVER! 9/28/2007

MY HUSBAND TOOK ME OUT FOR OUR ANNIVERSARY, GREAT SERVICE, FRIENDLY, NICE ATMOSPHERE AND GREAT FOOD. WE PLAN ON COMING BACK SOON! WE HAVE ALSO RECOMMENDED IT TO ALOT OF PEOPLE SINCE WE ATE THERE. I HAVE NEVER DONE A REVIEW, BUT THIS PLACE IS WORTH THE TIME. more

Great Steak 7/19/2006

Best steak, for the best price anywhere, try the large Filet you won't be disappointed. Friendly, good service each time we visit. Pros: prompt seating more

Great customer service 7/15/2006

My husband and I have been dining at Johnny's for five years. We have visited many other restaurants in the Milwaukee and also the Washington county area. NO ONE compares! Their food is OUTSTANDING! Johnny and Nancy couldn't be better hosts & their staff is always friendly and very helpful. I HIGHLY recommend this restaurant. You will NOT be dissapointed! We Love Johnny Manhattan's !! more

HIGHLY recommended 6/29/2006

Johnny Manhattan's is everything you're looking for in a fine dining restaurant. The owners John and Nancy walk around the whole place, stopping to talk to many customers, making sure everyone's enjoying themselves. I felt like family at Johnny's and their steaks are OUTSTANDING. I highly recommend this place. more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for Johnny Manhattan's




SUMMER SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 9/30/2018

Owner Message

  • Steaks, Chops, Pizza, Seafood, Italian Specialties, Nightly Specials, Pizza To Go, & More. A classy, but casual dining experience! We are nestled in the Northern Unit of the Kettle Moraine in the heart of Hubertus, WI, minutes away from Holy Hill.

Editorial

  • Restaurant features a selection of steaks, historic feel and fresh seafood platters.

  • 2/26/2007 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Tue 04:00pm-09:00pm, Wed 04:00pm-09:00pm, Thu 04:00pm-09:00pm, Fri 04:00pm-09:30pm, Sat 04:00pm-09:30pm
badge