I celebrated my birthday at Johnny Utah's last week. I haven't had this much fun in NYC in the last 2 years. I had dinner in the restaurant with a group of 15 close friends and then we stayed for the party scene after 11 PM. We sat in a private dining room which was very cool, since I wanted to spend quality time with my close friends. After 11, the place turned into a very fun party scene. I jumped on the bull and so did my entire group. The bull operator made us feel very comfortable and adjusted the levels depending on how good we all were. The entire place was cheering our name, which was very exciting. I've been doing the whole ""club scene"" the past 5 yeras. I wanted something different and non-pretentious. This was exactly that and I recommend it to any person wanting to actually have FUN on their birthday.
Pros: Easy entry, solid food, great atmosphere, quality service
Cons: Can't list any...I had a blast