JavaScript is not enabled.
I Tre Merli Bistro - 23 Reviews - 183 W 10th St, New York, NY 10014-3100, New York, NY - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (212) 929-2221

I Tre Merli Bistro

Claim
marker
183 W 10th St, New York, NY 10014-3100 (at nr. 4th St.)
New York, NY 10014
marker
(212) 929-2221
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

I Tre Merli Bistro - New York, NY
I Tre Merli Bistro - New York, NY

Reviews

( 11 )
( 9 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 2 )

Best

All I have to say is this: Every Time. What's that mean? Simple. Every SINGLE time I've been to this place has been a more pleasant surprise than the next. True, NYC has someth...

Worst

As a confirmed NYC foodie, I am willing to deal with small spaces and even bad service in return for good food. I Tre Merli unfortuntely was unable to deliver with the latter. C...

Check Them Out on Facebook: Honestly Amazing! 2/1/2011

All I have to say is this: Every Time. What's that mean? Simple. Every SINGLE time I've been to this place has been a more pleasant surprise than the next. True, NYC has something to fit every mood, to fill every plate, please every palate and abide to every need. However, as long as I've been here, I still find it rare to find a place that encompasses all of these things at once. Living around the block has allowed me to sink into I Tre Merli Bistro on several occasions, and I find it does just that. I have enjoyed Happy Hour drinks at their bar, extremely discounted lunch specials, incredible plates and fabulous wines. Better? I can afford it. Let's be honest, running around trying out all these places takes a toll on the wallet! This is someplace I would and have taken any guest to. From my sweet mother, to a romantic date, to a rowdy group of girlfriends, down to a co-worker and boss. It's intimate, but fun. Loud, but relaxing. Everyone has enjoyed it on each occasion. Major Suggestion: The Cheese plate. Though I think it's something like $18, it should honestly be more. It has more cheese and flavor than I've seen on any sad excuse for a 'cheese plate' in a long, long time. Definitely not a rip off - THING IS HUGE! Now I'm hungry. Check them out on Facebook too! more

Great brunch! 11/29/2010

I love this place for brunch. Even on the gloomiest of days, it feels bright and airy. The food is great, fresh, great value for the money. And most importantly, you'll love the people: warm, pleasant and polite, they won't rush you or disturb you. A great place to spend a lazy afternoon with a friend. more

Exquisite! 8/20/2009

The atmosphere is embracing, the food is delicious, prices very reasonable, the service accommodating! A pleasure and a great surprise. more

A + 11/19/2008

Food is well prepared, ingredients fresh.\r Service attentive, professional, friendly.\r Wine list surprising for such a small space.\r \r Loved it. For a neighborhood that borders on obnoxious, this place is a little gem. Rate this Bistro A + more

Great service 6/19/2008

Went to the Bistro last night for the first time. Had a fantastic time - just what we were looking for. Simple, well put together food, casual atmosphere and really knowledgeable service. We didn't feel rushed and felt welcome from start to finish.\r \r Great neighborhood find.\r \r Will definitely return soon. Pros: Service, atmosphere Cons: can't think of one! more

Loved it! 5/13/2008

We were walking around last night hoping to find somewhere cute to eat . We decided on ITM Bistro and loved it! The service was knowledgeable but friendly. It was nice to eat at a restaurant where the servers genuinely seemed to enjoy their work. \r \r Food was great and menu selection surprisingly varied considering how small the bistro is. Add a great bottle of wine to that, and our night was an A+ experience.\r \r Will definitely go back again. more

Great Place 5/9/2008

A Classic Bistro. Small, with a straight forward menu that doesn't miss. We are there once a week to have a glass of wine and a cheese board and some appetizers or a full meal. The staff is warm and knowledgeable, with a great wine list. We always get the fried mushrooms which are amazing. Pastas are delicious and the menu has something for everyone. Their ""sister"" restaurant has been around for almost 30 years, they must be doing something right! We are glad they are in our neighborhood.\r \r Pros: consistent, market fresh Cons: small, but what bistro is not... : ) more

Cozy spot, friendly staff 5/8/2008

It's true, it is tight, but that's because it's so popular. The food is good Italian fare. I was curoius to see if it was as good as their other, larger place on West Broadway. It certainly is. The atmosphere is upbeat and friendly, our server won us over with good knowledge of the wines and he seemed to be very genuine. \r This is a great little family spot in the village. The salami plate and a bottle of wine is great on an early spring evening, and everyone around us seemes to be enjoying their food very much. \r Definitely returning. Pros: Location, ambience Cons: Very tight between tables, but hey, you're in New York. more

good place if u want to get robbed 4/7/2008

not gonna lie the food is good sometimes nice italian dishes prepared by mexican cooks the drinks are really good even after they recycle them..i`ve seen them..the servers are amazing specially talking about their customers they are so polite at the table..but watch it when they go mumbling after they serve you..of course they treat you like family they are drunk out of their minds if not they wouldnt spill wine when they serve it..its a really nice place to get high with the staff if u stay after hours u can even snort some coke with the bartender if u tip him well..be careful with the pasta though once i saw it fall on the ground and then they just put it back on the plate and took it to the table like nothing had happened..the steaks are undercooked sometimes and the servers get angry if u send it back..the pasta is good but overpriced..the papardelle is the only good thing and the subs too..the wine selection is big i know but u can find the same bottles for half the price in a liquor store..the chesse board is good if u like beign charged double Pros: good location, nice drinks (sarcasm) Cons: all about it more

A real disappointment 2/10/2008

As a confirmed NYC foodie, I am willing to deal with small spaces and even bad service in return for good food. I Tre Merli unfortuntely was unable to deliver with the latter. Consequently, my wife and two of our friends spent the evening cramped into space the size of a postage stamp, Aside from the extremely small space, don't even try to get up to use the restroom, it requires the entire restaurant to get up from their tables, the service was horrible. In addition to the small space, the music was so loud that any attempt to engage in a conversation is simply futile. The waitstaff was mostly disengaged and the food was disappointing. The appetizers were uninventive and the salads were inedible. I ordered the pappardele which was average, but does not provide nearly enough of a reason to return to this restaurant.\r \r On the plus side, the location is great and the prices are low. If you don't have much of a palate, are on a budget and want to be in the middle of a hip area, I would say that I Tre Merli Bistro would fit the bill. If you are hoping for a little more, then I Tre Merli Bistro is not for you.\r \r Pros: Good location, cheap prices Cons: Food, service, small space, loud music more

Lamb Chops for $18, the friendliest staff, and... 10/9/2007

Lamb Chops for $18, the friendliest staff, and a great wine selection! more

Lamb Chops for $18, the friendliest staff, and... 10/9/2007

jcklngrn Provided by Partner
Lamb Chops for $18, the friendliest staff, and a great wine selection! more

Exellent for place for great food and atmosphere 7/19/2007

This is the perfect spot for a one-on-one dinner, whether it be with an old friend or a first date - the atmosphere allows for a great conversational meal. Start with the italian cheese and meat cutting board which at $18 is a steal (it is a cutting board piled high with foccacia squares and a variety of delectable meats, cheeses and marmalade). The pastas were delicious (one daily special was penne in red sauce with salmon and asperagus), creative, and perfectly spiced. The waitstaff helpful and attentive. It might feel a bit crowded in the winter, but on a recent summer night, with the windows open, it was just divine. Pros: Great food, great location, friendly waitstaff Cons: Hard to accomodate groups more than 2 or 3 more

best mushroom app 7/10/2007

You have to try it ! I live in the neighborhood and met a friend there for dinner on a friday night. The staff is very nice, but not to concerned with the type of service you get from bigger restaurants. Its not necessary though, since the place is so small you can always grab someone passing by. The pasta dishes are all fabulous and inexpensive. They are very prompt with drinks as well. You have to try the mushroom appetizer. They are fried in truffle oil and are genius. Definitely go for a low key night especially when there's a little breeze. Do go on a date if you want to talk intimately. Don't go in more than a group of 4. Pros: intimate, comfortable, tasty, cute, $35 a person with app and drink Cons: you might wait on yourself, but its not bad more

Hidden Hot Spot 2/26/2007

Went for the first time Friday with 2 friends. The staff is so accomodating. It is just the right size for an small get-together. The music (modern) was pumpin' but not overpowering. And no I didn't forget the most important thing...the food...Delicious. Definitley goes on the ""weekend dining out"" list. Pros: The service makes the experience even more enjoyable. Cons: None. more

So charming 11/5/2006

Whenever I find myself in the west village I try and stop at I Tre Merli for a glass of wine or a quick bite. The food is delicious, and the service is always friendly and polite, but what I like most about this place is the atmosphere. Its location and size makes it a perfect place to relax for a bit. You can never fit more than 20 people in there so you receive great service without the hustle and bustle of a larger restaurant. Pros: Relaxed, friendly staff more

Perfect 2/10/2006

I planned a small surprise gathering for a birthday dinner (8 people) and it was definitely the perfect place! They called me in advance to ask if I would mind coming in a little earlier and called to confirm my reservation as well...I don't think I have ever had a restaurant keep in such great contact! Everyone loved it--this place is such a gem! Pros: Inexpensive, Good food/wine, Location more

Disappointment 3/31/2005

after reading the review, we were sorely disappointed. The waitress was rude and neither of the waitstaff was assigned to a section of tables, as they constantly asked us the same questions, resulting in the food taking twice as long to come to the table. While the salmon had a delicious sauce, the portions were small. The steak was leftover gristle, and at $14 hardly a value. While the wine selection is nice, the staff is not trained in the edict of serving it. more

So good ! 11/27/2004

What a great little find in the West Village ! Very romantic, excellent and authentic Italian food and good service. Inn a neighborhood full of so so restaurants, this place is a winner. Pros: excellent food more

So tasty! 9/7/2004

We walked through the village looking for a nice place to eat, and discovered I Tre Merli. What a find! Excellent food and so reasonably priced. The waitstaff is wonderful and so is the wine selection! It's not large, but great for a dinner for 2 or group of 5-7. Pros: Waitstaff, Wine, Pricing more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for I Tre Merli Bistro




FALL SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 12/30/2018

Editorial

  • The Scene
    A mix of wallet-watching students, first dates and wine lovers share this casual, candlelit corner overlooking an active West Village intersection. Tiled floors, exposed brick,...

  • 10/8/2004 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Daily, 11am-midnight
  • Payments:

    American Express, Diner's Club, Visa, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods:

    Downtown, West Village
badge