True, I haven't been to Herb's in a few years, but I have trouble believing the really negative review by "drunktom". Perhaps the reviewer's name should provide a clue to the validity of his review. When I went there, the service was great, the food very good, and I listened to $5 worth of music. I plan on going back to the San Juans next spring and I can't wait to get back to Herb's!
Pros: Friendly staff, good food, great jukebox.
Cons: None--after all, this is a BAR--in case negative reviewers don't notice!