The Hearth is the new name for the Sugar Springs Restaurant, which has been in operation more than 30 years. In the not-to-distant past there were some PR issues, but this is changing for the better.
Food here has the quality you would expect to pay at least half as much again for (and the locals have realized this and appreciate it with greater numbers visiting regularly). I would advise calling ahead for reservations.
Pros: great food
Cons: limited seating