Artco Crafts is a small, friendly crafts store located on 6th Avenue. They're not too small to carry some items that the bigger stores don't have, however. For example, they're the only store that has the means to create drawer and doorknob pulls out of a special, pourable kind of material, complete with ink dyes, molds, and other materials necessary to the craft.
The staff at Artco is friendly, personable, and seem genuinely interested in helping with your project.
The rubberstamp, scrapbook, floral-and-ribbon departments are very good. The fabric area seems to only cater to quilters, which is unfortunate for those of us who need different kinds of fabric. The frame area is HUGE - the number of choices are truly awesome.
Artco has special drawings on some days, where a lucky person in the store can win a shopping spree. I never was fortunate enough to win yet, but I keep hoping!