I like Canter's as much as the next gal, but the food at Greenblatt's is truly superior. Plus, you can get a really great deal on a good bottle of wine. I have to recommend the kreplach, the salads, the kugel, and any of the myriad delicious desserts (cheesecake is to die for) but the star here is the tuna melt. I am a tuna melt aficionada, and this is probably the best one I've ever had (I get it on rosemary bread with tomato and aged cheddar). If I could make love to a sandwich, I would.
Pros: Tuna Melt, amazing winelist, dessert
Cons: No fries, sides extra, kinda pricey