Greek Tony's has been a Carmel staple for years. After moving to their new location in the early 90's it has had a continued stream of lunch time traffic as well as after-game pizza parties. Don't get me wrong, the pizza is good...real good, but you would be doing yourself an injustice not to try one of their subs. One, on their ever-growing list of yumminess. My personal favorite is the #3 The Mama's, but I also went thru a gyro, italian and a pizza phase, I now live in Broad Ripple where I am surrounded by food offerings everyday. I still make a point to drive to Carmel every know and then to have a taste of tried and true excellence.
Cons: Only one location