I love Graeter's ice cream. It is so creamy and flavorful. There are a lot of different regular varieties, and they also offer a couple seasonal flavors too. I love the chocolate chips they use in several of their varieties...they are so huge! They have great waffle cones/bowls dipped in chocolate, or you can have your ice cream in a regular cup, a malt, a milkshake, etc.
The one thing that I don't like about this location is that it is often busy and there isn't a whole lot of seating space.