JavaScript is not enabled.
Glass Nickel Pizza - 18 Reviews - 2916 Atwood Ave, Madison, WI 53704, Madison, WI - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (608) 245-0880
top 10

Glass Nickel Pizza

Claim
marker
2916 Atwood Ave, Madison, WI 53704
Madison, WI 53704
marker
(608) 245-0880
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

Glass Nickel Pizza - Madison, WI
Glass Nickel Pizza - Madison, WI
Glass Nickel Pizza - Madison, WI
Glass Nickel Pizza - Madison, WI
Glass Nickel Pizza - Madison, WI
Glass Nickel Pizza - Madison, WI

Reviews

( 11 )
( 5 )
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 0 )

Best

Great service, excellent pizza. Would eat again.

Worst

All reviews seem positive

Editorial review from GrubHub 6/11/2014

by Tom at GrubHub Provided by GrubHub
One of the Best Pizzas ever more

Editorial review from GrubHub 1/25/2014

Great service, excellent pizza. Would eat again. more

Editorial review from GrubHub 12/21/2013

The pizza I ordered was delicious ! Delivery time was fantastic .. very fast ... Will be ordering again ... :) more

Editorial review from GrubHub 12/9/2013

awesome food and fast delivery more

Editorial review from GrubHub 9/29/2013

Love the Thai Pie. Always on time! more

Editorial review from GrubHub 8/15/2013

The pizza was pretty good, but not enough for the price. more

Editorial review from GrubHub 8/15/2013

Always a great experience with Glass Nickel! more

Editorial review from GrubHub 6/11/2013

Perfect ! I love it! more


Editorial review from GrubHub 6/7/2013

Ravioli was great. Glass nickel is always high value for your money. more



Editorial review from GrubHub 1/3/2013

thought i was ordering chicken nuggs, but got bread bites instead. my mistake, but the bread bites aren't very good. they're soft and have no substance or flavor, plus they're pretty expensive (although you do get a lot of them) you should do something about that. Pizza was great as always :) thanks more

Great Local Pizza 5/27/2010

Glass Nickel East is a great option both for delivery or dine-in. Their east side location has a great vibe and the food is excellent. The Mediterranean pizza is one of my favorites. They also have comedy acts in the basement. When I've gotten food delivered from this restaurant, the drivers are always on time and are very friendly. more

Good pizza, nice ambiance 5/12/2009

I've been to a couple of the Glass Nickles in Madison and the surrounding areas, and I like this one on Atwood Avenue the best. The restaurant is very dark and homey, with high wooden booths that make for either a romantic or relaxed feel, whatever you're going for. We've gone for intimate dinners or to watch them play the Badgers games, and enjoyed it every time.\r \r The plain cheese pizza is a good benchmark of their pizza style. It has a thicker-style thin crust - thicker than NY-style thin, not cracker-thin, but not deep-dish either. It has a nice doughy flavor. They tend to use more sauce than cheese but the sauce is very flavorful, with hints of anise and oregano. If you're a cheese lover, definitely ask for extra cheese or half-sauce - they are VERY accommodating to special requests.\r \r The other menu items are good as well. The calzones and strombolis are excellent, huge with good cheese and fresh, flavorful fillings. The salads have never impressed me but they are generous and more

Editorial review from GrubHub 6/11/2008

The first night we ordered we got a alfredo pasta dinner and a pepperoni calzone. The delivery person was late, disgruntled, and shined a flashlight in our faces. The calzone was amazing, but the alfredo was terrible. The garlic bread was soggy and cold and the pasta was over sauced and clumpy. We complained and were refunded our order. We ordered again and got two sandwiches and the fried mac and cheese appetizer. Everything was on time, amazingly tasty, and well priced. It must have been an off-night the first time around! We will definitely eat there again. more

Not worthy of writing home about 3/17/2008

I am a lover of pizza and have been craving a good pizza for weeks. I decided to try out the Glass Nickel as it has been recommended. I ordered two different varieties of pizza trying to fully satiate my craving. Well, the pizza definitely did not fulfill my desires. It was alright, but definitely not something to write home about. more

Always a great pie at this place. i am a pizza junkie, an... 7/14/2007

Always a great pie at this place. i am a pizza junkie, and this place is near the top as one of my favorite... more

Always a great pie at this place. i am a pizza junkie, an... 7/14/2007

OldSkool Provided by Partner
Always a great pie at this place. i am a pizza junkie, and this place is near the top as one of my favorite pizzas. I love the dough bites too, but... more

awesome pizza AND the other stuff rocks too! 6/25/2006

OK, so I love their pizza. been eating it pretty much since they opened. BUt then they added salads (HUGE portions for cheap!) and subs and pasta..... i have not tried everything cuz i still get stuck on my faves. The fact they have had an actual place to eat in the last few years is great too. very cozy...not pretentious at all and fits into the east side well. Love the servers, they are down to earth but friendly. live music is loud sometimes....sux i fthe band is lame but fine if they have a good band playing. They should get a new menu though...they have lots of veggie and vegan things but you have to ask to find out what is in all the sauces,etc. Pros: neighborhood friendly, where the locals go Cons: not always enough room in parking lot on weekends more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for Glass Nickel Pizza




SPRING SALE!!!:
20% OFF all yearly plans
Use spring at checkout. Expires 6/30/2018

16 Years of Award Winning Pizza

Owner Message

  • * Locally Owned & Operated Since 1997* Open Late* Free Delivery. Pizza,Specialty Pizza,Pastas,Salads,Appetizers.

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Sun-Wed 10:30am-12:30am, Thu 10:30am-1:30am, Fri-Sat 10:30am-2am
  • Payments:

    Visa, Master Card, American Express, Discover
badge